Things From Movies That Cannot Exist Number 1: The Grapple Gun

The grapple gun is a staple of the action movie genre: simply point the hook skywards, fire and have the gun lift you onto the roof of your local Aban­doned Ware­house™ or Deserted Chemical Plant™. The Batman is par­tic­u­larly fond of the Grapple Gun, making it a staple of his famous Utility Belt.

So let’s look at the physics:

Assuming The Batman is a well-built adult male and that he’s wearing a sub­stan­tial amount of body armour and equip­ment, a mass of 150kg is probably reas­on­able. Raising a 150kg weight to the top of a ten storey (30m) building requires about 45,000 joules of energy (45 kJ). If The Batman takes thirty seconds to do the journey then that is equi­valent to a power of 1500 W. A motor capable of lifting The Batman’s 150 kg weight is probably about 75% effi­cient, meaning the motor has to develop about 2000 W.

If we assume that the grapple gun’s motor is no more than 5 kg in mass (for ease of wielding) that gives a power-to-weight ratio* of 400 W/kg. This is within the cap­ab­il­ities of modern electric motors, but only just. Finding a battery that can provide 45 kJ is not dif­fi­cult; lithium ion bat­teries can provide about 600 kJ per kilogram. However, they can’t supply that elec­tri­city quickly enough, managing only about 300 W/kg which means that the Grapple Gun’s 5 kg motor is going to come with a sub­stan­tial 5kg battery to match. Then there’s the weight of the gun itself and the super-strong cable to consider …

Whilst devices for firing grap­pling hooks do exist (I’m told the Battelle Tactical Air Ini­ti­ated Launch system is good) and powerful electric motors are fairly common, merging the two to create a useful handheld device is beyond the cap­ab­il­ities of physics at the moment. A real grapple gun would be far too bulky, heavy and unwieldy to be of any prac­tical use.

* Of course this should really be power-to-mass ratio, but I’m going to stick with the more commonly used term.

This entry was posted in General and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>